Skip to content
Best Logic for a Greener World

Referendum Loss Leaves Italy's Giorgia Meloni Looking More Vulnerable.

PM Meloni speaking about the vote outcome
The Prime Minister said the vote was a squandered moment to reform Italy.

Italy's Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni has faced rejection in a crucial national vote on reform, which ultimately became a broader verdict on her leadership.

The outcome awarded around 54% to the "No" faction and 46% to the "Yes" campaign that the Premier had strongly backed.

"The electorate have spoken decisively," she commented in a social media post, released even before all votes were finalized. "We will respect their choice, but I lament a missed opportunity to modernise the nation."

This represents the initial substantial defeat for PM Meloni and her center-right alliance, which has managed a atypical period of governmental steadiness for Italy. Rival factions are praising the outcome as a strong indicator that the public are desiring an alternative, with a national vote scheduled next year.

Ballot Tally

When the two-day referendum wrapped up on Monday afternoon, preliminary projections indicated the "No" campaign in front by a small gap. But, that advantage grew to a considerable one as the ballot counting unfolded.

Despite the complicated issue on the voting slip, participation was nearly 60%. A strong participation had been widely expected to aid the government, but it proved insufficient to swing the outcome.

The Defeated Proposal

The proposed change that voters turned down would have inscribed a firm separation between judges and prosecutors into the nation's charter. It further suggested distinct institutions to govern them and a novel disciplinary court.

The Meloni cabinet contended the change was vital to improving judicial independence. Critics argued that it would upset a careful equilibrium put in place following the fall of the fascist regime, and amplify governmental sway over the judiciary.

Numerous Italians reportedly struggled to grasp the nuances – maybe a communication failure by her government – and the ballot rapidly became a plebiscite on her lengthy three and a half years in government.

Celebrations by 'No' supporters
Opposition voters gathered to celebrate their triumph.

A Difficult Context

The setback came at a challenging time. The Prime Minister is a key partner of ex-US President Donald Trump, whose approval has diminished in Italy, along with approval of his approach on the Middle East conflict.

Furthermore, with Italy's financial health sluggish, numerous citizens are worried about the war's consequences on fuel prices and the cost of living.

Fallout

The Premier had always ruled out stepping down, regardless of the result. This differs from the approach of former PM Matteo Renzi in 2016, who initiated his own constitutional referendum as prime minister and resigned after losing.

"This referendum is not about me, but about reform," Meloni had stated before the poll.

Once the outcome became clear, Renzi counselled that her administration had now lost its "popular appeal" and needed to pay closer attention to the electorate. "Suffering a defeat and walking out whistling just isn't an option," he remarked to Italian radio.

A victory would have almost certainly emboldened her to pursue other political ambitions, like a subsequent change to introduce a popular vote for the premier.

Conversely, opposition PD head Elly Schlein declared that Meloni's defeat showed "there is an other option to this government" in the run-up to next year's parliamentary polls.

This setback has stripped some of the luster off the ruling alliance and Meloni herself, hitherto regarded as the strong woman of Italian politics, has been made appearing more vulnerable.

The writer

Stephanie Blackwell

Environmental scientist and tech journalist covering green innovations.

Best Logic for a Greener World

Type to search articles.